permalink  Going By The Numbers

Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math.

In a previous article, Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror, we compared the numbers of United States citizens killed by illegal aliens to the tally of our troops killed in the war on terror. In response to that article, one of our readers wrote asking whether we had seen the video produced by NumbersUSA titled Immigration by the Numbers. He asked, “I wonder how accurate it is?”

This widely distributed video uses gumballs in a jar to visually demonstrate the impact of numbers that increase exponentially rather than linearly. These are mathematical concepts that are immediately meaningful to folk with a technical background, but may be harder to understand for others. The answer to our reader’s question is that the video IS accurate. It is not based on partisan opinion. It is just a very graphic illustration of an algebraic equation.

You can view a clip from the video here. Roy Beck of NumbersUSA is not depending on any esoteric data. He’s just doing the math, based on the US Census numbers, which actually grossly UNDERESTIMATE the number of illegals in the United States.


The gumball video is just a reprise of that old high school science experiment in which you have a population of fruit flies — Drosophila — that doubles with every generation. (The reason they used fruit flies is that drosophila require only a week to ten days to reproduce, and you can easily get the experiment done during a thirteen week class term.)

You fill the jar 1/8 full with fruit flies. It looks like there is a lot of room left. Next thing you know, the jar is 1/4 full. Then 1/2 full. But not to worry, because there is still half of the whole jar available for them to fly around in. And then — WHOOPS — the jar is jammed full, and they begin to die.

However, in the video, Roy Beck uses gumballs instead of fruit flies.


For a population to grow in numbers, more children must be born than the number that are needed to replace the older folk who are dying. If every man and woman pair off monogamously, and we don’t allow for a slight variation due to women who die before childbearing years, simple replacement requires that every woman have two children (one to replace herself and one to replace her man). If every woman had four children during her childbearing years, the population would double every generation like the fruit flies, sans devastating war, terrible famine and pandemic lethal disease like the black plague.

Mexican immigrant women (legal and illegal) living in the United States have a fertility rate of 3.51 according to the 2002 US census. So their population will not quite double, but it certainly will increase at a very rapid rate. And whereas the educated American population may defer marriage and childbearing until they are adequately prepared to raise a family, the immigrants will produce “anchor babies” as soon as biologically possible, no later than age 18, because we as taxpayers will support them. So our “jar,” the continental United States, will fill up pretty rapidly.

But mathematically it gets worse, much worse. The parents do not die when the kids are born as the fruit flies do. So now within four years, the 2 parents and their 3.51 kids are all living here. Illegals are coming at the rate of about one million per year from Mexico, according to the latest estimates by border patrol agents. So within four years, each annual increment will have become 2,755,000 mouths to feed — the original million plus the 1,755,000 children that the 500,000 women in the increment will have produced.

500,000 x 3.51 = 1,755,000 children per annual increment

1,000,000 original illegals + 1,755,000 anchor babies = 2,755,000 new faces

In less than eleven years, that’s 10% of our current population. And please note, this analysis only includes parents who are ILLEGALS. It does not include anchor babies born to parents who are here legally on work visas, and produce offspring for the sole purpose of staying. It also does not include the huge jump in numbers that will occur eighteen years out, when the children of the illegals start reproducing.

What makes these considerations most galling, however, is the fact that this high birth rate of 3.51 for Mexican women living illegally in the US is evoked by the deep pockets of the American taxpayers. It only occurs in the benevolent social welfare context of the United States. Mexican women living in Mexico have a birth rate of 2.4 children.

Bookmark and Share

Send a link:  Tell a friend about this.
Link to this post:  Permalink
Send us your link:  Trackback link
Filed under: Illegal immigration



35 Responses to “Going By The Numbers”
  1. Charlie H. says:


    Thanks for the article. The differential birthrate of Mexicans in the US and Mexico is another interesting statistic that gives pause for thought / conjecture.

    Your article also got me to thinking about ” anchor babies “. This situation needs to change. Very few politicians have the guts to bring these issues up during elections. ( Or any other time. )

    Anchor Babies

    The more info ya got the more questions ya have.

  2. Nancy K. Matthis says:

    Thanks for sharing that link, Charlie. I had not seen that article. It is an attention grabber!

  3. Guard the Borders says:

    [...] Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis [...]

  4. Euphoric Reality - » Guard The Borders Blogburst: Dec 11 06 says:

    [...] Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis [...]

  5. “7.62mm Justice” » Guard The Borders Blogburst Dec 11 2006 says:

    [...] Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis [...]

  6. Stuck On Stupid says:

    Guard The Borders Blogburst

    Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math. In a previous article, Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror,…

  7. Gun Toting Liberal » Blog Archive » Bloomberg A Maverick? Give Me A Break says:

    [...] ***** On the matter of illegal immigration, this weeks’ Guard The Borders Blogburst was written by Nancy Matthis of American Daughter: Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis [...]

  8. Mover Mike says:

    Guard the Borders Blogburst

    Going By The Numbers
    by Nancy Matthis

    Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math.

  9. Customerservant.com: Definitely Not Good For The Company » Blog Archive » Guard The Borders Blogburst, 11 December 2006 says:

    [...] Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis [...]

  10. Freedom Folks says:

    Guard The Borders Blogburst

    Going By The Numbersby Nancy MatthisUnderstanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is …

  11. Right on the Right » Going By The Numbers says:

    [...] Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis [...]

  12. American Daughter Media Center - Front Page » Blog Archive » Guard The Borders Blogburst says:

    [...] Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis [...]

  13. Independent Conservative says:

    Will Illegals the Numbers Don’t Lie!

    This week’s GTB Blogburst has numbers to ponder.
    Going By The Numbers
    by Nancy Matthis
    Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math.
    In a previ…

  14. RIGHT WING HOWLER says:

    GUARDS THE BORDERS BLOGBURST

    Going By The Numbers
    by Nancy Matthis
    Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math.
    In a previous article, Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror, we compa…

  15. pamibe says:

    Guard the Borders Blogburst

  16. The Amboy Times says:

    GTB Blogburst

    Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math. In a previous article, Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror,

  17. NIF says:

    Monday = GTB!

    Today is Monday, which means it is time to pause and reflect on border security …

  18. A Lady's Ruminations says:

    Guard the Borders Blogburst

    Going By The Numbersby Nancy MatthisUnderstanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is …

  19. Right Truth says:

    Guard the Borders Blogburst 12/11/06

    Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math. In a previous article, Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror,

  20. Woman Honor Thyself says:

    Guard the Borders Blogburst

    Going By The Numbers
    by Nancy Matthis
    Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math.

    In a previous article, Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror, we comp…

  21. Church and State says:

    How Simple is the Math

    Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis

    Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math.

  22. novatownhall blog says:

    Immigrants, Numbers and Crime

    In this post we’re going to cover a few issues related to the problem of illegal immigration in the U.S. First is crime. Last week’s Guard the Borders Blogburst homes in on the simple fact that some illegal aliens commit…

  23. The Irate Nation says:

    GTB – Going By The Numbers

    Going By The Numbers by Nancy Matthis Understanding the impact of illegal immigration does not depend on accepting partisan opinions. It is just the result of doing some simple math. In a previous article, Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror, we …

  24. Bear Creek Ledger » Guard The Borders Blogburst - 12/12/06 says:

    [...] Guard The Borders Blogburst – 12/12/06 Filed under: BlogBursts/Blog Memes, Illegal Immigration, DHS — Toni @ 6:36 am Going By The Numbers  by Nancy Matthis  [...]

  25. American Daughter Media Center - Front Page » Blog Archive » The Price Of Lettuce says:

    [...] The Crider Case Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror Going By The Numbers getSphereItResults(’inline_sphereit’) ; [...]

  26. Guard the Borders says:

    [...] The Crider Case Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror Going By The Numbers [...]

  27. Euphoric Reality - » Guard the Borders Blogburst: Dec 18 06 says:

    [...] The Crider Case Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror Going By The Numbers [...]

  28. “7.62mm Justice” » Guard The Borders Blogburst 12-18-06 says:

    [...] The Crider CaseIllegals Deadlier Than War On TerrorGoing By The Numbers [...]

  29. Customerservant.com » Blog Archive » Guard The Borders Blogburst, 18 December 2006 says:

    [...] The Crider Case Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror Going By The Numbers [...]

  30. American Daughter Media Center - Front Page » Blog Archive » Guard The Borders Blogburst says:

    [...] The Crider Case Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror Going By The Numbers [...]

  31. BobGriggs.com » The Price of Lettuce says:

    [...] $80 x 52 = $4,160 per yearAnd if you can shave a similar amount off the wages of a gardener who fine-tunes your boxwood and manicures your grass one day per week (say $25 per hour instead of $35 per hour), you can double your savings. These wages are the going rates in the DC suburbs where our lawmakers have their posh dwellings. Throw in the Hispanic nanny who tends the little ones 48 hours per week while you are at work, and this becomes very attractive. So the “Tijuana express” IS benefiting the folk who are responsible for keeping the underground railroad running. But let’s be honest. This is not about the price of lettuce. For an overview of our government’s history of disastrous meddling in the agricultural economy, read Agricultural Subsidies in the HighBeam Encyclopedia here. Previous articles in our Illegal Immigration series: The Crider Case Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror Going By The Numbers This has been a production of the Guard the Borders Blogburst. It was started by Euphoric Reality, and serves to keep immigration issues in the forefront of our minds as we’re going about our daily lives and continuing to fight the war on terror. If you are concerned with the trend of illegal immigration facing our country, join our Blogburst! Just send an email with your blog name and url to admin at guardtheborders dot com.   [...]

  32. Mover Mike says:

    Guard the Borders Blogburst

    By Nancy Matthis at American Daughter
    Today’s Blogburst is also available as a Podcast.

    The Price of Le…

  33. Swap Blog » Blog Archive » Price of Lettuce says:

    [...] The Crider Case Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror Going By The Numbers [...]

  34. Bear Creek Ledger » Guard The Borders Blogburst - 12/19/06 says:

    [...] The Crider Case  Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror  Going By The Numbers  This has been a production of the Guard the Borders Blogburst. It was started by Euphoric Reality, and serves to keep immigration issues in the forefront of our minds as we’re going about our daily lives and continuing to fight the war on terror. If you are concerned with the trend of illegal immigration facing our country, join our Blogburst! Just send an email with your blog name and url to admin at guardtheborders dot com. [...]

  35. American Daughter Media Center - Front Page » Blog Archive » Thank God For Advocacy Groups says:

    [...] The Crider Case Illegals Deadlier Than War On Terror Going By The Numbers The Price Of Lettuce getSphereItResults(’inline_sphereit’) ; [...]