permalink  Obama Lied to Congress

During his speech last night, Obama flatly stated that illegal aliens would not be insured under his health care bill. From the floor, South Carolina Representative Joe Wilson called out, “Lie.”

Obama: “There are also those who claim that our reform efforts would insure illegal immigrants. This, too, is false. The reforms… the reforms I’m proposing would not apply to those who are here illegally.”

Wilson: “You lie.”

Obama: “It’s not true…”

Here’s the exchange:

At best, Obama was using a semantic ploy to mislead the audience. Illegal aliens will not all be in possession of a piece of paper titled Health Insurance Policy. But they will be assured of receiving care any time they need it at the taxpayers’ expense. If they go to any emergency room they will receive care — it’s the law.

And many will also get care under the provisions of the current health reform legislation, in direct contradiction to what Obama claimed. This is not just the opinion of a group opposed to the legislation. It is the finding of the Congressional Research Service (CRS). From the CRS report Treatment of Noncitizens in H.R. 3200 (PDF), August 25, 2009, under the heading Exchange:

H.R. 3200 does not contain any restrictions on noncitzens — whether legally or illegally present, or in the United States temporarily or permanently — participating in the Exchange.

So, as per this government report only two weeks old, whether intentionally or unintentionally, tonight Obama stood before Congress and lied to the members. Rep. Joe Wilson has read the bill. Barack Obama has not read the bill, and is relying on his handlers to tell him what to say.

Politicians on both sides of the aisle called upon Wilson to apologize, which he did. Many, including John McCain, seemed to think that Wilson was rude for calling out from the audience. Personally, I believe that Obama was rude for lying to Congress and to the American citizens who were watching and listening. And Obama was arrogant and disdainful for assuming that we are stupid enough to believe his lie.

ActBlue immediately created a fund-raising page for Joe Wilson’s 2010 Democratic challenger Rob Miller titled No More Name Calling. So far they have raised a grand total of $100 from three supporters. And Wikipedia had to disable editing of their article on Joe Wilson due to vandalism.

Which is more important — the veneer of manners or the gut of honesty? Have any of these pantywaists ever watched a session of the British parliament?

In any event, the future probably will favor Wilson. We understand that he has aspirations for higher office, and the governorship in his state may soon be vacant. In this timely moment, he has just become a national ideological hero. He gave voice to the frustrated silent majority, and they are ecstatic:

The shout heard round the world!!
The new battle cry of all TRUE AMERICANS: YOU LIE!!!!!
Joe has just been launched into superstardom.
I want to bear his rebel children!!!
I’m definitely adding him to my list of Great Americans!

Before the Obama speech, Joe Wilson had 2,800 followers on Twitter. Within an hour after his shout, he had more than 4,200 followers. From Twitter:

45 min. Primetime Speech $72M, Obamacare $1.6T, Pelosi’s face after Obama called a liar…Priceless

Here is the priceless moment after:

The priceless moment after

Tweets about the Obama speech:

“Pimping dead Ted”
“BS from BO”

Bookmark and Share

Send a link:  Tell a friend about this.
Link to this post:  Permalink
Send us your link:  Trackback link
Filed under: Health care, Healthcare
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


8 Responses to “Obama Lied to Congress”
  1. And So I Go: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow says:

    [...] You may also want to check out: Obama Lied to Congress By Nancy Matthis [...]

  2. amf says:

    For Immediate Release
    Contact: Diane Havens
    September 3, 2009
    (201) 819-6405
    admin@hearthebill.org
    Now You Can HEAR What’s in the Proposed Health Care Reform
    Legislation in Congress
    Rising Above the Acrimony of Town Hall Meetings, New Web Site Features Voice Actors
    Reading the Bill So Americans Can Decide for Themselves
    A group of voice actors is making a lot of noise about the proposed health care reform bill
    working its way through Congress – but not the kind of noise heard recently across the
    country at Congressional town hall meetings.
    Instead, the actors have read the bill – all 1,018 pages of it – and made the legislation
    available as an audio book, online at http://www.hearthebill.org .
    “Health care reform is an issue that affects everyone, but it’s been difficult for many people
    to cut through the spin of various interests and learn directly what’s in the legislation,” said
    Kathleen Keesling, who designed the site, and who, along with fellow voice actor Diane
    Havens, had conceived the idea of producing an audio version of the proposal. “Now there is
    a place where everyone can go to read and listen to the bill, educate themselves, ask the
    right questions for clarification – and then make their own determination about whether to
    support it.”
    Using the site is free. In all, over 80 voice actors volunteered to read sections of the
    legislation.
    “We put out a call on voice over forums, blogs and social networking sites to see if there
    was interest among our colleagues for reading sections of the legislation, and we were
    overwhelmed,” Havens said. “Immediately, dozens of voice actors responded, and we were
    off and running. People were eager to contribute to helping all Americans know what’s in
    this proposal and how it could have an impact on their lives.”
    The HR3200 bill is fully downloadable and indexed like an audio book, allowing users to
    choose which parts they want to hear at their own convenience. It also provides the sightimpaired
    with an option they otherwise would not have. Others can read along with the
    audio, and should keep checking back, as the site will be updated whenever the bill is
    amended to ensure that it remains current.
    # # # # #

  3. Priceless! « THE MILLSTONE DIARIES says:

    [...] by Nancy Matthis at American Daughter [...]

  4. Right Truth says:

    Fact Checking President Obama …

    A friend emailed me this morning asking if anybody is ‘fact checking’ President Barack Obama’s speech last night on his proposed health care. My first reaction was, “Bwahahahahah, every word out of his mouth was a lie or mis-representation” Hubby….

  5. Obama Lied to Congress « Right Sided American Kafir says:

    [...] : “http%3A%2F%2Fwaltjr.wordpress.com%2F2009%2F09%2F10%2Fobama-lied-to-congress%2F” } Source:  American Daughter Thanks [...]

  6. GOODNESS WORLD LIFE BLOG says:

    [...] OBAMA LIED TO CONGRESS By Nancy Matthis | Thursday, September 10th [...]

  7. » Financial News Update – 09/10/09 NoisyRoom.net: Where liberty dwells, there is my country… says:

    [...] Obama Lied to Congress [...]

  8. cpm says:

    Um, look at Section 246 of the bill.